men riding horses in a rocky valley

Good, Bad, Ugly: What’s New in the ETF world

In the past, talking about ETFs meant talking about low-cost, passive, index-tracking investment products. They were boring, but they were a welcome relief from the world of mutual funds1 and their often sky-high management fees.

Nowadays, ETFs of all stripes are popping up everywhere. And while some continue to adhere to the old tenets of boring, passive and effective, some of them sound like bad ideas, or even worse, sound like something that belongs in a casino. Let’s take a look at a few I’ve taken note of in the last little while.

Good: Scotia’s new all-in-ones

While researching my Gravy train calls on Scotia iTrade, TDDI and TD Easy Trade post, I stumbled across a recently-released family of all-in-ones from Scotia. I’m a big fan of all-in-ones, as they combine hundreds of stocks and bonds in a single product, all with automatic rebalancing. 75% of my RRIF investments are tied up in XGRO, an 80% equity, 20% bond fund, and is the flagship member of my magnificent seven ETFs.

Scotia’s new ETFs are not as obviously named as competitive products (that double-barrelled “SB” for Scotiabank gets in the way), but at least they are staying consistent with the competition:

  • SBEQ2: 100% Equity (43% US3, 25% Canadian4, 22% Developed markets, 10% Emerging Markets)5
  • SBGR6: 80% Equity/ 20% Bonds (34% US, 20% Canadian, 18% Developed, 8% Emerging, 20% Canadian Bonds7)
  • SBBA8: 60% Equity / 40% Bonds
  • SBCN9: 40% Equity/ 60% Bonds

You can review them in greater detail over here.

Anyway, they seem fine, other than being a little too internationally-focused for my liking. But the price is certainly right. They launched in October 2026, and aren’t charging any management fee until October 2027, and a low 0.15% MER thereafter. That’s worth something. And free to trade on all the usual platforms (Wealthsimple, Questrade, BMOI, DisNat) as well as (unsurprisingly) Scotia iTrade.

Bad: So many multi factor ETFs

No doubt inspired by the debut of CAGE (I wrote about this one over at CAGE versus XEQT: what’s the deal?) on the Canadian market, there are now a whole raft of similar sounding ETFs out there.

  • LTCE is a Canadian equity fund that uses “multi-dimensional investment approach that integrates fundamental, quantitative, and trend analysis to identify stocks exhibiting a compelling combination of qualitative merit, attractive financial characteristics, and positive momentum”. MER = 0.60%. Ouch.
  • DSCA is a Canadian equity fund that “uses a systematic investment process that aims to outperform its benchmark index over the long term”10
  • and others…

I dunno, these just seem a way to increase MERs for not very much potential benefit. I’ll stick with passive and boring, I guess.

Ugly: single stock ETFs

Don’t feel like you have enough exposure to Nvidia? There’s an ETF for that! Want 2x performance? That’s NVDL. Want covered call Nvidia? That’s NVDY. Want both? That’s NVII.

Gambling, in my estimation, is best done at a casino. At least you might get a free drink now and then. These ETFs are just gambles on a single stock, and it’s not just limited to Nvidia — I’ve seen similar products trumpeting the wonders of SpaceX, Apple, Alphabet, Tesla… No thanks. I’d rather hold all the stars, and a few dogs along the way as I invest in boring index funds. I sleep well.

  1. My journey as a DIY investor started back while I was still in university when I bought some mutual funds from a “new” company called Altamira. As I recall, I got a presentation from a rep at my parent’s house. Humble times. ↩︎
  2. Competitors: XEQT, VEQT, TEQT, ZEQT ↩︎
  3. All held in SITU, which does NOT track the S&P 500 index, but rather the 500 largest US companies. This sounds suspiciously like the same thing. My AI friends tell me that they may differ “at the margins” (i.e. the smaller of the 500 companies). Maybe I’ll see at some point. ↩︎
  4. Uses SITC, which doesn’t use TSX 60 as the reference index but rather “the 60 largest Canadian companies”. Tomato, tomahto. ↩︎
  5. That’s a very high allocation to equities outside North America. For reference, the other *EQTs stay at a 20% allocation. ↩︎
  6. Competitors: XGRO, VGRO, TGRO, ZGRO ↩︎
  7. All held in SITB: about 75% are government bonds, 25% corporate. ↩︎
  8. Competitors: XBAL, VBAL, TBAL, ZBAL ↩︎
  9. Competitors: XCON, VCNS, TCON, ZCON ↩︎
  10. Aim all you like, but active managers don’t outperform passive indices over time. ↩︎
train with yellow locomotive riding on railway tracks by the hayfield

Gravy train calls on Scotia iTrade, TDDI and TD Easy Trade

The promotional gravy train, which seems to be an ongoing thing in the online broker world, keeps chugging along. Free money is on offer if you are willing to move your assets into either Scotia’s or TD’s online arms. But they are quite different, especially for those of you (like me) who are already retired.

TD offer

TD’s offer (all details here) extends to new and existing clients, on either of their platforms: TD Direct Investing (aka TDDI) and TD Easy Trade. If you register, fund and keep your money at TD, you can get 2% cash back on eligible registered accounts and 1% cash back on eligible non-registered accounts, to a maximum of $15,000.

The fine print immediately eliminates this offer from my consideration: RRIF and RESP accounts are not eligible and hence I’ll not give this offer a 2nd look.

For those still holding RRSPs, this seems like a pretty generous offer. If the combined value of your RRSP and TFSA exceeds $750k, you’d be eligible for $15k of free money; not bad for a few hours’ work.

TDDI isn’t a platform I know well, and it lacks some of the features I consider table stakes nowadays (e.g. commission-free trading on ETFs1), but people seem to like it well enough.

Scotia iTrade

Scotia’s offer (all details here) might be even better, though. Scotia is offering 3% cash back on registered accounts, 1% on non-registered accounts. And, importantly, Scotia’s offer includes RRIFs and RESPs as well as TFSAs and RRSPs. They also have a cap at $15,000. But the 3% threshold means you only need $500k of registered assets to hit the ceiling, an even better payout than TD’s.

Scotia iTrade isn’t a super-popular platform, and, like TDDI, they don’t offer across-the-board commission-free ETF trading. They also have a list of free-to-trade ETFs, and their list happens to include my #1 holding, XGRO.

Anyway, perhaps worth a closer look. Free money always gets my attention!

In summary

Here’s what the offers look like side by side:

TDDIScotia iTrade
Cash back limit$15k$15k
Registered investments2% cash back, excludes RRIF and RESP3% cash back, includes RRIF & RESP
Non-registered investments1% cash back1% cash back
Open new account by ….April 30, 2027April 1, 2027
Fund account by….May 31, 2027May 31, 2027
Minimum amount of new funds$10k$5k
Hold funds in account untilMay 31, 2028March 31, 2028 / February 28, 2029
PayoutJune 202840% after March 2028, 60% after February 2029

For me, the winner is iTrade in this round. What do you think about these offers? Let me know at comments@moneyengineer.ca!

  1. TDDI offers a stack of commission-free ETFs, including some that I actually own and some all-in-ones (TEQT, TGRO) that I’d also consider ↩︎

sign in a window

Tax planning in retirement: non-registered asset sales

My retirement savings1 are spread across multiple kinds of accounts: primarily RRIF, but there’s also TFSAs and non-registered accounts. Here’s today’s snapshot, courtesy of my multi-asset tracker:

For tax reasons2, about 2/33 of this year’s salary is actually funded by my non-registered accounts. But I hold a bunch of assets in both my and my spouse’s non-registered accounts, each with their own adjusted cost base, each in a position to generate a capital gain when sold, each representing a tax obligation for one of us. Assuming I’m trying to reduce CRA’s take, how do I decide which asset to sell at any given time?

Let’s start with some principles that I try to keep in mind as I work through that decision.

Principle #1: Try to equalize our taxable income

Why equalize? Because Canada’s tax system is graduated (i.e. it has tax brackets), the more you earn, the higher your overall tax rate is. It therefore follows that the minimal possible tax bill is generated when both members of the tax household make close to the same taxable income. A quick example: here I’m using the advanced Canadian Tax Calculator, and assuming that all income below is employment income, with no special deductions, and using Ontario as the location of the primary residence:

My IncomeMy Tax BillSpouse’s IncomeSpouse’s Tax BillTotal Tax bill
100k17.1k0017.1k
80k14.1k20k.1k14.2k
70k11.1k30k2.5k13.6k
60k8.3k40k4.4k12.7k
50k6.25k50k6.25k12.5k

In each case (row) above, the total household income is 100k, but the lowest tax bill comes when each spouse is earning 50k. Equalizing the income makes for the smallest tax hit.

In retirement, income looks a bit different. Taxable income for our household comes primarily from four sources, which I summarize for you:

Income SourceMe My Spouse
EmploymentEssentially 0not 0
RRIF paymentsYesYes — the same as me4
Capital GainsYes – variableYes – variable
Dividends, InterestA bitEven less
TotalRRIF + variable capital gains + a bit of dividend/interestEmployment + RRIF + variable capital gains + even less dividend/interest

Employment and RRIF payments are known at the beginning of the year, and dividends and interest can be estimated within an acceptable range (they are small compared to other chunks of income, anyway). That leaves the capital gains portion of the income to worry about, and it’s variable because of course it depends on what I sell, when I sell it, and who gets the tax attribution.

What’s clear from my table above is that my capital gains attribution needs to make up for the extra income my spouse earns — an employment salary — if I want to meet my goal of equalizing our income.

Principle #2: Get rid of tax obligations early

I figure it’s better to pay taxes sooner rather than later. In the case of my non-registered assets, given that they are 100% equity, they are only going to grow (on average) over time and give me a larger tax liability down the road. And dying with non-registered assets is the worst from a tax perspective, since CRA treats that as a “deemed disposition”, meaning that dead you is effectively taxed as though you sold everything all at once. A tax time-bomb.

So to help with that, I not only track my adjusted cost base per unit for each asset I own, but I track the capital gain per dollar liquidated. Let’s look at some examples:

Asset SymbolACB per share (A)Current Price (B)Capital gain/share (B-A)Capital gain / Dollar (B-A)/B
HXS58.20106.7948.59.455
HXT48.3696.2347.87.497
HXDM39.1264.4325.31.393
  • ACB per share: I track ACB of all my non-registered assets using adjustedcostbase.ca
  • Current price: Current as of market close November 5, 2026 per googlefinance()
  • Capital gain per share: The difference between the market price and my average cost. Your actual capital gain reported to CRA for a given “sell” transaction is this value multiplied the number of shares you sold.
  • Capital gain per dollar: helps me decide which shares to liquidate. Higher means a higher capital gains for the same amount of money, meaning a higher tax liability. Since I’m selling shares with the intent of generating part of my retirement paycheque, knowing the capital gain for liquidating (say) $10000 of HXS is way more meaningful to me than knowing the capital gain involved in selling 100 shares. And it quickly gives me a way to quickly calculate the impact of a given sale on taxable income.

So if I needed $10,000 I could:

  • Sell 93.64 shares of HXS and generate a capital gain5 of 10000*.455 = $4,550
  • Sell 103.38 shares of HXT and generate a capital gain of 10000*.497= $4,970
  • Sell 155.21 shares of HXDM and generate a capital gain of 10000*.393 = $3,930

You could say that selling HXDM is the correct approach since it generates the lowest amount capital gains, but I usually select the one with the worst outcome, in this case HXT. Why? Stocks tend to go up over time6, and I figure by trimming the biggest gains first will save me tax money in the long run.

What it effectively means

The strategy therefore becomes pretty easy to articulate: every tax year, sell assets in my non-registered account until such time as my taxable capital gains equal my spouse’s salary7. After that, try to finesse any remaining monthly payments so that our taxable incomes are (roughly) equal. I’m working on automating some of those calculations.

  1. You can read about how I classify what counts as retirement savings over here: What’s included in your “retirement bucket”? ↩︎
  2. My reasoning is to get rid of “extra” sources of income early in retirement, before CPP and mandatory higher RRIF payments kick in. And having fewer accounts to manage as I get older seems like a good idea, too. ↩︎
  3. 63% if you want to be exact ↩︎
  4. Both me and my spouse are the same age, and our RRIFs are very nearly equal in size. Score one for me on the planning side. ↩︎
  5. That’s raw capital gain, not taxable capital gain. For every $10000 my spouse earns, I get $20000 in raw capital gains to equalize. ↩︎
  6. Not steadily, of course, but I don’t claim to be able to predict near term futures. ↩︎
  7. This is only possible because my wife only works part time, so her salary contribution to the overall household income is modest. ↩︎

cheerful woman with donation box

Donating Shares with Wealthsimple

Donating shares instead of cash to your favourite charity is something I’ve discussed previously, and it’s an outstanding way to do good while at the same time reducing your tax bill more than you might expect!

Donating shares directly has a double tax benefit:

  • You get the usual charitable donation credit that’s equal to the fair market value of the shares on the day they are transferred
  • AND you don’t have to worry about any capital gains for this transaction. They are essentially forgiven. Nice.

In retirement, I’ve not yet taken advantage of this benefit; instead, I just carried on with supporting my usual charities through monthly deductions, normally paid for with my credit card. Mostly it’s laziness; I don’t really have to think about the monthly donation and the charities get a steady stream of cash from me. Also, as mentioned elsewhere, I’m a cheapskate, and the fee that Questrade chooses to levy on such transactions1 seems mean-spirited and pricey.

But I do hold a few shares at Wealthsimple, so I figured I’d see how easy or hard that would be. I wanted to send the Ottawa Food Bank and Salus some shares, so I went to work. Wealthsimple’s own help page is surprisingly helpful.

Step 1: Find charity-specific security donation forms

These forms are generically referred to as “Letters of Direction”. Larger charities often have their own forms; smaller charities that don’t can also receive donations by using a service like CanadaHelps. Both the Ottawa Food Bank and Salus have their own:

These forms are all a little different, but are generally looking for things like

  • The security name and symbol you’re wanting to donate
  • The CUSIP of the security to make absolutely sure it’s the right one (a quick google search reveals this)
  • Account number of the account that holds the security in question
  • How many shares you want to donate
  • Approximate value of the shares you want to donate
  • Name and contact info for your broker

Step 2: Fill out the form and upload it to the Wealthsimple portal

The Wealthsimple portal’s “Documents” section is found under your profile if you’re using the website.

It’s pretty easy.

Step 3: Contact Wealthsimple support to let them know

This I chose to do at around 8pm on a weeknight and I chose to use chat. And you know what? I got connected to a real live person pretty quickly and that real live person knew what they had to do, and they did it2. All of this took perhaps 10 minutes. If this sounds painfully ordinary, I can assure you it is rather atypical in the world of online brokerages. I received email confirmation from the front line agent within minutes, and the next day I got contact from the team responsible:

I’ve submitted both donation requests, one for each charity, to our team for review and processing. Share donations typically take 7–10 business days to process.

What happens next

Once your shares have been sent, we’ll send you an email update. You can then confirm receipt directly with each charity. Our team will review each Letter of Direction and process the donations as instructed. If we need anything else from you, or if there are any issues with either request, we’ll reach out to you right away.

There’s a few things notable about this communication:

  • It’s not a form letter. Or if it is, it’s been edited, since I did indeed make two donations at the same time.
  • It’s written in clear English.
  • It sets expectations clearly and concisely.

I’d like to tell you that this is no big deal. But it is. This kind of clear, concise communication is shockingly rare. It’s pretty awesome.

Step 4: Let the charities know what’s coming their way.

The forms from Ottawa Food Bank and Salus each had different ways they asked to be contacted if you donate securities. Just emails, nothing more.

Step 5: See the shares leave your account

News flash: this happened THE SAME DAY I was contacted by the team responsible. I’m gobsmacked at this point. Nothing in DIY investing is ever this fast!

Step 6: Await charitable donation receipt

Salus sent this to me yesterday, two days after the shares left the account, three days after I submitted the forms. Ottawa Food Bank told me the amount, and promised a receipt next week.

This was, if I’m honest, way easier and less hassle than I anticipated. Wealthsimple gets 5 out of 5 stars for their involvement. And they charged me nothing. Next time, I’ll try it with Questrade. I’m not so certain it will go as smoothly.

  1. Can’t find mention of the fee, but I was told by support (which may depend on who one talks to and what day of the week it is) that $25 will be charged. I guess I’ll just have to try and see at some point. ↩︎
  2. Which was to direct my query to the correct team. I don’t expect product expertise at 8pm on a weeknight, but I do expect if live people are online, that they have sufficient training to handle these kinds of requests. ↩︎
abundance of food on table

What’s in my retirement portfolio (October 2026)?

This is a monthly look at what’s in my retirement portfolio. The original post is here.

Portfolio Construction

The retirement portfolio is spread across a bunch of accounts:

  • 5 RRIF accounts
    • 3 for me (Questrade, Wealthsimple)
    • 2 for my spouse (Questrade)
  • 2 TFSA accounts (Questrade)
  • 4 non-registered accounts, (1 for me, 1 for my spouse, 2 joint, all at Questrade)

The view post-payday

I pay myself monthly in retirement, and the charts that follow reflect the view post-payday, which happens around the end of the month. On October 29th after the markets closed, this is what it looked like:

The portfolio is dominated by my ETF all-stars, aka the Magnificent Seven ETFs list.

This is pretty much the same chart as last month. I’m sort of expecting that to be the case month-to-month. Every month there are small reductions in my XGRO position1 since that’s what I sell to make my monthly RRIF payments. There are slightly larger reductions in the non-registered part of the portfolio to pay my salary, but their contribution to the overall picture is pretty negligible. HXT is the largest non-registered holding I have now, followed by ZMMK and XIC. Everything else you see on the chart above is either in my RRIF or my TFSA.

My asset allocation targets are unchanged, namely:

  • 5% cash/ultra short term bonds
  • 15% bonds
  • 23% Canadian Equity
  • 37% US Equity
  • 20% International Equity

The asset-class split looks like this; you can read about my asset-allocation approach to investing over here.

This chart is an almost-perfect reflection of my asset targets, with all categories within 0.5% of the intended allocation.

Plan for the next month

Nothing looming; no planned changes. My spouse’s RRIF is 0.24% larger than mine, which is a tiny improvement over last month; ideally the values of our RRIFs would be equal so we withdraw the same amount and draw the same RRIF salary. Makes things a bit easier to plan.

I have been looking again at perhaps moving XGRO over to ZGRO.T to take advantage of ZGRO.T’s automated payouts, which would simplify my monthly RRIF routine considerably. Unless I can be reasonably sure ZGRO.T will generate enough income on a monthly basis to fully cover my foreseen monthly payouts, there’s really no compelling reason to do that.

Overall

Part of using VPW as a strategy is the need to calculate your retirement net worth on a monthly basis. My net worth took a small hit this month, but the trend remains positive overall:

My VPW-calculated salary has now increased for 10 straight months; it’s nice getting a monthly raise! I should start to see the salary flatline if the net worth remains flattish (as it has for the past 6 months now).

  1. And 4 times a year, that reduction is VERY small since XGRO pays quarterly dividends which are by default used to purchase more of the same. ↩︎